Last November, self-righteous, condescending, and professional internet troll blogger
Matt Walsh posted
this article entitled, "If You Shop on Thanksgiving, You Are Part of the Problem," and after being picked up by
Huffington Post it quickly began making the rounds on Facebook. It's a post decrying the bloated growth of Black Friday to the point where our
national day of Thanksgiving could now more accurately be called Black
Thanksgiving (coincidentally also the name of my unwritten
holiday-themed horror movie), as well as assigning the blame for the moral crumbling of a great American tradition to shoppers looking for a deal. And his views haven't changed given this recent tweet:
We live
in a country that has a nasty problem with consumerism and debt,
and stores being open for big sales on Thanksgiving is really all the
evidence you need that the problem is getting worse. But now that we're well into another November, faux concern and anger over this practice is again spreading online, and I can't help but try to illuminate Matt and those who feel the same way he so surely does to the bigger picture that they are clearly missing (or simply choosing not to see). Just because you don't go shopping doesn't mean you're not a part of the same problem you're so seemingly miffed at.
Matt writes:
Capitalism is great, but some things are greater. Family is greater.
Yes, these folks choose to work at these stores. Yes, they likely knew
when they signed up that they'd be sacrificing their Thanksgivings. Yes,
at least they have jobs. Yes, sure, and so what? If that's enough in
your mind to justify participating in the destruction of a great
American tradition -- good for you. But you COULD wait until Friday,
couldn't you? And if you did wait until Friday, and if everyone waited
until Friday, no store would ever open on Thanksgiving again, right? So
you COULD take steps to protect Thanksgiving from the decay of
materialism and consumerism, and, while you're at it, give this
wonderful holiday back to the customer service representatives who have
been forced to abandon it and cater to the stampeding throngs, right?
An interesting point there, and in light of it I would like to ask Matt, and
everyone else who is outraged over stores being open on Thanksgiving, a
few questions.
To start: do you watch football on Thanksgiving? Have you
ever spent your holiday going to a game? If so, have you ever thought
about all the people who have to work to make the game and the broadcast
happen? The last game was less than 3 days ago on Monday night - can't
you wait until Sunday for another? And if you did wait until Sunday, and
if everyone waited til Sunday, no football game would ever be played on
Thanksgiving again, right? From parking attendants, to ushers, to
security, to food service workers, I'm sure they're all more than happy
to give up their Thanksgivings so that you can sit home or in the
stadium and enjoy yours more. But it's OK, because football makes the
day more bearable and it's
tradition, right?
Have
you ever been to the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, or watched it on
TV? Have you ever thought of the number of extra cops who have to work
because of that 4-hour commercial which, by the way, has become a
glowing symbol of the very consumerism you have such a problem with?
What about all the workers who have to staff the businesses along the
parade route? I went to the parade when I was in 7th grade. We took a
Metro-North train into the city, had lunch at McDonald's in Times Square, and
froze our asses off. But it's OK, because it's
tradition, right?
One
of my biggest pet peeves with holidays in general is that once 8PM
rolls around, most everything is done with and there's really nothing to
do...but you can always go to the movies. Have you ever gone to the
movies on Thanksgiving? Do you think the people who sell you your
ticket, sell you your snacks, run the projectors, and then clean the
theaters are simply not interested in spending time with family and
friends? I don't know, but regardless it's OK, because after all nothing
says "giving thanks" like catching one of the probably 17 Thanksgiving Day
showings of
The Hunger Games: Mockingjay, Part 1 at your local Regal, right?
Lots
of people consider it a holiday to not have to cook on Thanksgiving.
Have you ever eaten at a restaurant on Thanksgiving? Maybe a Denny's.
What about gotten coffee at a diner or a drink at a bar with some
friends that you don't see very often? Do you think the wait staff and
cooks have an aversion to being in close quarters with loved ones, and
therefore are cool with working? Maybe it's a family establishment and
so it's all good because they're all in it together. I really don't
know.
If you are cooking, are you doing it all by candlelight over a campfire in your backyard? I doubt it, which means you're going to be using plenty of electricity and possibly gas, and you must realize that those services simply don't run themselves. Someone has to be manning the system, and someone has to be ready to go into the field to deal with emergencies and outages.
Occasionally when you're in the midst of cooking a meal you realize we forgot to buy something, and Thanksgiving is no different. So what do you do? Go out to the supermarket to grab it? If you couldn't remember the cranberries before the big day can't you just go with out them on the big day? Think of those people working the checkout register.
If you were to call 911, would you expect someone
to answer and help to be sent your way? Probably. I have a paramedic
friend who has worked Thanksgiving for years, and not because he doesn't
like turkey.
What happens when you're on the way to grandma's and you realize your car is running is on empty?
Now of course I'm embellishing the point to drive it home - unfortunately that's what you have to do to compete in the bullshit hyperbolic, absolute "truth teller" world that an internet arbiter like Matt Walsh thrives in. Nuance is for lesser thinkers. This Thanksgiving I might watch
football (though I'm not a huge fan), may watch the parade (though I
find it kinda boring), and might hit a diner, grab a drink, or see a
movie (though probably not
The Hunger Games). I doubt I'll call
911, but who the hell knows? I won't be doing any shopping, but I
also won't be under the delusion that nothing I do this holiday will
have a negative impact on other people. Companies like Wal*Mart who
employ workers at low wages
and use shady
compensation tactics to prevent them from truly making holiday pay
should of course be ashamed of themselves, but the emergence of more
"open for
business" signs on Thanksgiving is merely an extension of a problem in
America that has been building for years and years: those who can
afford it will have good holidays, and those who cannot will work.
And
just like you're so upset about Thanksgiving Day sales, I guarantee
that in 10 years you will be flipping a shit if they decided to end
them.
Because by that time it would be
tradition, right?